Fair Trade Commission Guidelines on Additional Fees Charged by Distribution Enterprises

Passed by the 470th Commissioners' Meeting on November 9, 2000
Promulgated by Order(89) Kung Yi Tzu No.03967 on November 30, 2000
Passed by the 688th Commissioners' Meeting on January 13, 2005
Promulgated by Order(94) Kung Fa Tzu No.0940001305 on February 24, 2005
Passed by the 738th Commissioners' Meeting on December 29, 2005
Promulgated by Order(95) Kung Fa Tzu No.0950000132 on January 9, 2006

1. Purpose of the Guidelines

The Guidelines have been specially adopted to prevent distribution enterprises from abusing advantageous positions in the market by improperly charging suppliers additional fees, and thereby to maintain the market trading order and ensure fair competition.

2. Definition of distribution enterprise

The term "distribution enterprises" as used in these Guidelines refer hypermarkets, to convenience stores, supermarkets, department stores, consumer cooperatives , and all other enterprises engaged in general merchandise delivery and selling business..

3. Definition of additional fees

The term "additional fees" as used in the Guidelines, with the exception of amounts payable for goods by the distribution enterprises, refers to fees charged to suppliers by distribution enterprises, or to deductions made from amounts payable for goods, or to all kinds of fees demanded of suppliers by distribution enterprises by other means.

4. Factors to be considered in determination of advantageous market position

In determining whether a distribution enterprise holds an advantageous position in the market, the following factors must be considered: the comparative scales and market shares of the distribution enterprise and supplier; the supplier's degree of dependence on the distribution enterprise; the supplier's ability to change its sales channel; and supply of and demand for the goods.

5. Entering into written agreements

When a distribution enterprise asks a supplier to bear additional fees, it should first negotiate with the supplier with respect to the type of additional fee, its use, and the amount of the fee (or the method of its calculation), and enter into a written agreement with the supplier.

6. Provision of information for direct debiting of additional fees

When a distribution enterprise charges its supplier additional fees by directly debiting its account payable for goods purchased, it must provide information regarding the deduction prior to deducting the additional fees.

7. Practices constituting improper charging of additional fees

Under anyone of the following circumstances, a distribution enterprise shall be deemed to be improperly charging additional fees:

(1) the fees charged are not directly related to promoting the sale of the goods;

(2) the fees charged are contributions to equipment, research and development, or promotional activities, and while of benefit to the supplier in promoting sale of goods or reducing operating costs, the amount of the fees exceeds in value the tangible benefit that the supplier may reasonably expect to derive from paying such contributions;

(3) the fees charged are for the sole purpose of achieving target figures or other accounting measures at the end of a fiscal year;

(4) when, despite the supplier being under no obligation, a reduction in the purchase price is demanded by the distributor for already-delivered goods; or

(5) fees are charged in a manner contrary to normal trading principles or commercial ethics.

8. Violation of the Guidelines

If a distribution enterprise having an advantageous market position charges suppliers additional fees in a manner not in accordance with Points 5 and 6 of the Guidelines or is found to be in violation of Point 7 such that the distribution enterprise market order is impacted, the distribution enterprise shall possibly deemed to be in violation of Article 19(1)(vi) or Article 24 of the Fair Trade Law.